Classic Creamy

Product image 1Classic Creamy
Product image 2PB Love Co Classic Creamy Nut Butter close-up detail image.
Product image 3PB Love Co Classic Creamy Nut Butter open jar top view image.
Product image 4Classic Creamy
Product image 5Classic Creamy

Regular price $21.50

Purchase Options
Delivery Frequency

FREE DELIVERY with a minimum order of $35.  City of Denver addresses only.

Simple, smunchy, with a smooth, sticky finish. It is what it is - straight-up peanut butter. 

ingredients: dry roasted peanuts

Stone-ground peanuts. No heat, no processed junk, just peanuts and a lot of handmade love. This is the choice for those looking for ultimate simplicity with just a touch of smunchiness.


Customer Reviews

Based on 26 reviews
Carol Skarlat
Best PB Ever

This is great peanut butter. Much better than commercial brands and even store ground. The peanuts used are high quality.

The secret is our stone grinding process, and our hands on approach to every batch!

Thanks for being such a fan!

M. Sheehan
It's the best!

My whole family loves the all!

Dan Murray
The Best Creamy Peanut Butter

I've tried several "organic" or "all natural" peanut butters over the years because I love peanut butter but can do without the sugar and whatever else from the big brands. The PB Love Co creamy peanut butter is easily the best I've ever had. I don't know what the secret is but the flavor and consistency was really unexpected. Amazing peanut butter (never thought I would care so much about a PB but there are so many products out there making outlandish claims, so it's nice to have one live up to the hype).

No secret, just a jar full of stone ground roasted peanuts.

Sam comb

Classic Creamy

Leslie Lippert
The best!

Love to cute guy who packs it too!

I heard he's super funny and has a wicked synthesizer collection too.

Close (esc)


on your first purchase of premium peanut & almond butters. You'll also be rewarded handsomely with giveaways, news, recipes & promotions, but not too often.

Age verification

By clicking enter you are verifying that you are old enough to consume alcohol.


My Cart

Your cart is currently empty.
Continue shopping