Classic Creamy

Product image 1PB Love Co Classic Creamy Nut Butter 7.75oz jar image.
Product image 2PB Love Co Classic Creamy Nut Butter close-up detail image.
Product image 3PB Love Co Classic Creamy Nut Butter open jar top view image.
Product image 4PB Love Co Classic Creamy Nut Butter three pack image.
Product image 5Classic Creamy

Regular price $19.50 Sale price $22.50

FREE DELIVERY with a minimum order of $30.  City of Denver addresses only.

Simple, smunchy, with a smooth, sticky finish. It is what it is - straight-up peanut butter. 

ingredients: dry roasted peanuts

Stone-ground peanuts. No heat, no processed junk, just peanuts and a lot of handmade love. This is the choice for those looking for ultimate simplicity with just a touch of smunchiness.


Customer Reviews

Based on 19 reviews
So good!

Only PB I buy and love to gift it to my friends - so good!

Why we love PB Love

We first met Mario (founder) at a farmers market and sampled all of his different peanut and almond butters. We have been been huge fans ever since. His products are exactly what you would expect from and artisan who loves his craft. Classic Creamy peanut butter is a wonderful tasting, easy spreading peanut butter. It is what its called...Classic.

Thanks for the kind words Robert. We hope to see you at the local farmers market this summer!!


so good. so, so good.

Thanks for the kind words Amy!!

Looking forward to feeding you again soon!!

Five hearts for PB Love

We love PB Love Co peanut butter! You make delicious products, and the delivery is amazing. We have ordered many many jars of the classic creamy peanut butter. Thanks for recognizing our repeated orders, too...we love the spatula!

Margaret, thanks you for being such a fan of PB Love. When we found these cool little spatulas, we knew our customers needed to get their hands on one.


Best Peanut Butter Cookies Ever

As soon as I received my shipment of this peanut butter (in Michigan), I used the peanut butter cookie recipe from the PB Love newsletter and made the cookies for the holidays. They are, flat out, the best peanut butter cookies I’ve ever made or eaten! I used the Classic Creamy peanut butter and am so happy with the flavor. Thank you for the idea!

Its always so exciting to hear about how people use PB Love in their cooking. Keep us posted about the yummy things you make with PB Love!!


Close (esc)

Live in Denver? Receive FREE delivery!

We deliver twice a week for FREE to any City of Denver address. 

Learn More

Age verification

By clicking enter you are verifying that you are old enough to consume alcohol.


My Cart

Your cart is currently empty.
Continue shopping